North West Music Logo
Home Folk Forum Gigs Artists Sessions and Sing Arounds Events Store Links Contact
Friday, 28th April 2017
music feed Subscribe to North West Folk

The Gentle Good: Ruins/Adfeilion

RuinsThere's an odd noise on Ruins/Adfeilion, title track of the new album from The Gentle Good.  It sounds like an exhaust pipe scraping on the floor after it's fallen off your car.  If you're listening whilst driving,  as your reviewer was, it's somewhat alarming.

There are earlier horrors.  Jacques Brel once sang about the 'rancid sound of the accordian'. On opening number Gwen Lllw'r Lillm it's 'turgid' and 'harmonium'.  Please stop. 

Then we're into a song in Welsh.  Gareth Bonello may be proud of his roots, and he's welcome to that, but performing in a tongue that hardly anyone can understand is a an effective a way of reducing the size of your audience, and as everyone knows, the Welsh language was only invented to make the lives of those who work in call centres more difficult.

Yet here's the paradox.  Once it's been established that your mode of transport isn't falling to bits, then  Ruins/Adfeilion, a piano led instrumental, reveals itself as melancholy and beautiful, especially in the phase before the horns kick in.  Pen Draw'r Byd has a gorgeous melody and sumptuous harmonies and probably other words that end in 'ous'.  Who cares about the language?

It's a theme that runs through the album.  Some parts are naff, others sublime.

Rivers of Gold is a protest song (in English).  It's quite a pretty waltz which can be swayed to, should you wish to mock  Whilst the sentiments are admirable (the poor getting poorer, rich getting richer) Bob Dylan won't exactly be shitting himself.

The vocal style - a cross between California and the Wicker Man is too gentle for this listener's ear .  Of course that's a matter of taste, but vocalists who sound like they've had some pain in their lives are more interesting.

Given that view, it won't be surprising that top billing as far as this piece goes, is awarded to Un I Sain Ffagan, a guitar instrumental that's complex, medieval and reminiscent of British finger style great Dave Evans.

There are a few parts of Ruins/Adfeilion that grate (like that exhaust pipe, which turned out to be thunder.)  But the excellent composition and outstanding musicianship in other sections more than compensates.  The Gentle Good is worth a gentle look.

- Les Pilling


The Gentle Good

Latest Folk Music News
John Boden - Painted Lady Mal Robins damns with faint praise
The Gentle Good: Ruins/Adfeilion Naff and rather good as well
Ben Glover: The Emigrant Trad reviewer Mal Robins put Mr Glover through his paces. There are problems
Heidi Talbot - Here We Go, 1, 2, 3 A first release since 2013 and sadly it's a dud
Seth Lakeman - Ballads of the Broken Few New NWF Reviewer Mal Robins Takes on Seth Lakeman
Upcoming: Will Varley - Kingsdown Sundown New album and UK and Ireland Tour
Folk Festival on the Dock Host and new acts announced
More Articles...

            Join us on