North West Music Logo
Home Folk Forum Gigs Artists Sessions and Sing Arounds Events Store Links Contact
Monday, 24th April 2017
music feed Subscribe to North West Folk

Lisa Knapp - Hidden Seam

Lisa Knapp Hidden SeamThe opening track of an album can be a full blown statement of intent.  Or at other times it's the number that eases you in, with the meat to arrive later.  Shipping Song, which introduces Hidden Seam, the new release from Lisa Knapp is something else.  It's a collection of sounds rather than a song, and five minutes of your life that you won't get back.  Apparently, it was written, if that's the right word, due to a fascination with the shipping forecast.  Not that you'd know if it wasn't in the accompanying PR leaflet.

Following on from this is the title track, which does appear to have a tune lurking amongst the whale noises.  But two minutes from the end it dissolves into a cacophony of grunts, squeaks and sighs that make you wonder if Ms Knapp is on the end of an enthusiastic rogering.  At this point your reviewer was thinking of alternative uses for a cd.  Like a coaster, or even better a frisbee.  At least you could throw the damn thing away then.

Redemption for this nonsense arrives late with Hunt the Hare Part II featuring Scottish musician Alasdair Robert and originally based on the Irish song Rocky Road to Dublin.  It starts off Celtic and morphs more into Applachian as mid point is reached.   Good stuff, and one of the few points where the lyrics are distinguishable, but by now we're at track eight of nine.

Earlier, Two Ravens, with Martin Carthy guesting had given hope, but the hook which kicks in as the song gathers pace has a plodding arrangement to work against and ultimately it's a disappointment.  But then that's one of the problems that runs throughout.  There's never a gathering of momentum.

Overall, Hidden Seam is forgettable.  It's an album oddly lacking in warmth, with insufficient substance and a lot of frilly window dressing to plug the gaps.

- Les Pilling

Links

Lisa Knapp






Latest Folk Music News
John Boden - Painted Lady Mal Robins damns with faint praise
The Gentle Good: Ruins/Adfeilion Naff and rather good as well
Ben Glover: The Emigrant Trad reviewer Mal Robins put Mr Glover through his paces. There are problems
Heidi Talbot - Here We Go, 1, 2, 3 A first release since 2013 and sadly it's a dud
Seth Lakeman - Ballads of the Broken Few New NWF Reviewer Mal Robins Takes on Seth Lakeman
Upcoming: Will Varley - Kingsdown Sundown New album and UK and Ireland Tour
Folk Festival on the Dock Host and new acts announced
More Articles...

     
            Join us on